Buying A Car Privately Vs From A Dealer In NZ - The Pros And Cons

In New Zealand, the decision to purchase a vehicle from a registered dealer or a private seller involves several legal and financial considerations. Both paths offer distinct advantages, but they also carry different levels of risk and protection under New Zealand law. Understanding these differences is essential for making an informed investment and securing the right financing for your needs.

Buying From A Registered Motor Vehicle Trader

Purchasing from a dealership is the most common route for those seeking convenience and security. Registered motor vehicle traders are subject to strict regulations that provide high levels of consumer protection.

When you buy from a dealer, your purchase is covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act. The CGA ensures that the vehicle is of acceptable quality, fit for its intended purpose, and matches the description provided. If a fault develops shortly after purchase, the dealer is legally obligated to provide a remedy, which may include a repair, replacement, or refund. Furthermore, dealers must display a Consumer Information Notice in the window of every used car. This document provides vital details about the vehicle history, its fuel economy, and whether there is any money owing on it.

Dealerships offer a streamlined experience, they handle all the paperwork, including the transfer of ownership with the New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA). Most dealers also accept trade-ins, allowing you to use the value of your current car as a deposit for your next one. Because they have physical premises and a reputation to maintain, it is often easier to resolve disputes or access after-sales support.

Buying A Vehicle Privately In New Zealand

A private sale occurs when you buy a vehicle directly from an individual who is not in the business of selling cars. This is often the preferred choice for bargain hunters or those looking for specific older models.

Private sellers do not have the overhead costs of a car yard, such as rent, staff wages, and marketing. As a result, the purchase price is often lower than what you would find at a dealership. There is also typically more room for negotiation, especially if the seller is in a hurry to finalise a sale before moving or purchasing another vehicle.

The primary drawback of a private sale is the lack of legal recourse. The Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act do not apply to private transactions. Most private sales are conducted on an as-is-where-is basis. This means that if the engine fails or a major electrical fault appears the day after you buy the car, the cost of the repair falls entirely on you. While you are still protected under the Contract and Commercial Law Act if the seller intentionally misleads you, proving this in the Disputes Tribunal can be a difficult and time-consuming process.

How Financing Differs Between Dealers And Private Sales

The way you fund your vehicle changes significantly depending on who you are buying from. It is important to compare these options before you commit to a purchase.

Dealer Arranged Finance

Most dealerships have relationships with specific finance companies. This is known as point of sale finance. You can choose a car and secure the loan in a single location.

Pros:

• Exclusive Finance Deals: You may find you get access to manufacturer and promotional offers, especially for new or late-model cars (manufacturers sometimes offer low-interest rates to move stock).
• On-Road Costs Can Be Included: Dealers often bundle the cost of registration, a full tank of fuel, and even initial service plans into the finance package. This means you do not need to have extra cash on hand to cover these initial ownership expenses.
• Enhanced Consumer Protection: When you use dealer finance to buy from a registered trader, you are operating within a highly regulated environment. This provides a reliable safety net.
• One-Stop Convenience: The most immediate advantage of using dealer finance is the streamlined experience. A dealership acts as a single point of contact for the entire transaction. You can select the vehicle, test drive it, negotiate the price, and finalise the loan all in one afternoon.

Cons:

Dealers often earn commissions on these loans, which may mean the interest rate is higher than what you could find elsewhere. Additionally, dealer finance is usually tied to a specific vehicle; if you change your mind about the car, you must start the application process over again.

Finance For Private Sales

When buying from a private individual, you cannot use dealer finance. Instead, you must secure a personal loan or a specialised vehicle loan from an independent finance company or your bank. Combining a private purchase with independent vehicle finance offers a balanced approach to car shopping. You benefit from the lower prices of the private market while maintaining the financial structure and professional oversight of a regulated lender. This strategy provides the tools to negotiate like a cash buyer while ensuring that the vehicle you are buying is legally clear and mechanically sound.

Pros:

Potentially Lower Price Points: In the private market, sellers are often motivated by speed and simplicity. They may be selling at a lower price than if you were to find the same car in a dealer's yard (who has to account for overheads and commissions etc).

• Greater Flexibility: Independent finance allows you to shop around. You are not restricted to the inventory of a single dealership or a specific chain of car yards. Whether you find the perfect car on an online auction site, a social media marketplace, or a local noticeboard, your finance moves with you. This flexibility is particularly useful if you are looking for a specific make, model, or colour. You can take your time to find the exact vehicle you want, knowing that your funding is ready to go once the right opportunity appears.
• Pre Approval Rocks! This effectively turns you into a cash buyer, giving you more leverage during negotiations with a private seller. Coming to a negotiation with finance already in place gives you a significant advantage. A private seller is much more likely to accept a lower offer from someone who can settle the payment immediately rather than waiting for a buyer who still needs to figure out their budget or apply for a loan.
• Peace Of Mind: Using a professional finance company also adds a layer of protection to the transaction that you do not get with a pure cash sale. Before a finance company releases funds to a private seller, they perform several essential checks. These include:
• PPSR Verification: The lender will check the Personal Property Securities Register to ensure there is no existing debt or security interest on the vehicle. This protects you from buying a car that could be repossessed due to the previous owner's unpaid loans.
• Ownership Confirmation: The finance company verifies that the person selling the car is the legal owner and has the right to sell it.
• Mechanical Integrity: Many lenders require a professional pre-purchase inspection before approving a loan for a private sale. While this is an additional step, it ensures you are not financing a vehicle with hidden mechanical failures.

Cons:

Since the lender cannot rely on a dealer to verify the vehicle condition, they may require a pre-purchase mechanical inspection before they release the funds. In a private sale, the lender will be particularly focused on the Personal Property Securities Register. If the seller still owes money on the car to another finance company, that company has a legal right to repossess the vehicle, even after you have paid for it. Independent lenders will check the PPSR to ensure the title is clear before the loan is finalised.

Essential Pre-Purchase Checks For Every Buyer

Regardless of whether you choose a dealer or a private seller, certain steps are mandatory for protecting your financial interests.

1. Mechanical Inspections: A Warrant of Fitness is a safety check, not a mechanical one. It does not guarantee that the engine is sound or that the transmission is in good health. Always invest in a professional pre-purchase inspection from a provider like the AA or a trusted local mechanic.
2. Background Reports: Always run a vehicle history check using the registration plate. This will confirm the odometer history, check if the car has been reported stolen, and verify if it has a consistent service record in New Zealand.
3. PPSR Checks: For private sales, a PPSR check is the only way to confirm there is no debt attached to the vehicle. If you buy a car with an active security interest, you risk losing both the car and the money you paid for it.

Choosing between a dealer and a private seller depends on your priorities, but by securing independent finance before you start shopping, you maintain the flexibility to choose the best vehicle from any source while ensuring your interest rates remain competitive. Need vehicle finance today? Give the team at CarMoney a call to discuss your car loan options now.

‍